Speaking For Parrots

Parrots need your voice

Parrot Feather Picking, Self-Mutilation, and Other OCD Behaviors: It’s Not Your Fault.

In the bad-ole-days, if you had a parrot who had some kind of feather destructive behavior (FDB), or self-mutilated, you were stigmatized. You were accused of not providing enough toys and enrichment, feeding a poor diet, not spending enough time with your parrot, or whatever was the “New Black” for why parrots in captivity expressed these behaviors. Well, except for captivity itself.

mutilating-quaker-jen-budrock

AvianAwareness.tumblr.com

We know that some of these harmful behaviors are medical in nature. We also know some are quite common, as stated in the opening sentence in the abstract for “Feather Loss And Feather Destructive Behavior In Pet Birds,” by Rubenstein and Lightfoot in Journal Of Exotic Pet Medicine:

Feather loss in psittacine birds is an extremely common and extremely frustrating clinical presentation. Causes include medical and non-medical causes of feather loss both with and without overt feather destructive behavior. Underlying causes are myriad and include inappropriate husbandry and housing; parasitic, viral and bacterial infections; metabolic and allergic diseases; and behavioral disorders. Prior to a diagnosis of a behavioral disorder, medical causes of feather loss must be excluded through a complete medical work-up….

Yet, more often than not, the cause is never identified, and once all medical avenues have been exhausted, the diagnosis is behavioral. When people start looking for help in the behavioral realm, they are thrust into a world of DVDs, books, seminars, Facebook groups, YouTube videos, and trainers for hire either in person or remotely (e.g., FaceTime, Skype). So many try and try and try the different methods, yet still so many fail. Why?

I have attended seminars, watched DVDs, read books, joined Facebook groups and talked directly with trainers and behaviorists, and the answer to why so many afflicted parrots and so many failures was alarming. Much of the blame is still dumped in the laps of guardians. It comes in different forms, but essentially it’s assertions like: they haven’t had the right information (maybe meaning “buy our DVD, not theirs”), they didn’t do the right things (e.g., they didn’t find the right motivator/reward/treat), they are doing something to reinforce the behavior, or they are neurotic themselves (human psychology?).

heidenreich-its-not-your-fault-photo-1

 

whittaker-its-not-your-fault-photo

 

kashmir-its-not-your-fault-photo

 

laurella-its-not-your-fault-photo

But what conclusion do you come to if over and over you see people who are doing everything they’re told? Why are people still having behavior problems with their parrots even when they did all the research before getting a parrot, bought DVDs,  joined Facebook groups, and brought their parrot to a board-certified avian vet for a battery of tests? I see good people all the time whose parrots are so troubled. They do all the “right” things they are told to do by vets, trainers and breeders, but they still have no success. They are wracked with guilt for their suffering beloved parrot, and then someone tells them they’ve created the behavior or made it even worse!

mutilation-goffins-mytoos-com-1

Mytoos.com

Are they all really making  mistakes in the value of their rewards, or following the wrong information, or are they very neurotic themselves? Or is it something else?

Considering that the incidence of behavioral issues is so great in the captive parrot population as a whole (as stated by Rubenstein and Lightfoot), and that many of the these behaviors are also seen in other captive,  non-domesticated animals, like chimps and elephants, we must ask if it’s captivity itself that is the problem.

But, if the root cause is captivity, that doesn’t sell parrots, DVDs, seminars, tools, supplements and every other “snake oil” being pitched by the different barkers. Those on the supply side of behavior problems give examples of how they changed X-amount of parrots with their wares. Some parrots have stopped biting and others have stopped screaming. They’ve learned to to give high-five, play dead, put balls in baskets, and other things that can keep parrots (and people) from getting bored; however, there are a lot of parrots who are so troubled they don’t respond to the methods taught in DVDs, seminars and books. Specifically, it’s because these methods don’t assess and treat the trauma of living in an alien world.

poster-mutilation-grey-cheryl-rutherford

ForParrots.com

We know there are abnormal behaviors (behaviors not expressed in the wild) exhibited by other captives. There are even some who are saying, as in this paper, “How Abnormal Is The Behaviour Of Captive, Zoo-Living Chimpanzees?” after setting up experiments, that in certain species, some kind of abnormal behavior is exhibited in all the members of the group, regardless of environment:

Our overall finding was that abnormal behaviour was present in all sampled individuals across six independent groups of zoo-living chimpanzees, despite the differences between these groups in size, composition, housing, etc. We found substantial variation between individuals in the frequency and duration of abnormal behaviour, but all individuals engaged in at least some abnormal behaviour and variation across individuals could not be explained by sex, age, rearing history or background (defined as prior housing conditions). Our data support a conclusion that, while most behaviour of zoo-living chimpanzees is ‘normal’ in that it is typical of their wild counterparts, abnormal behaviour is endemic in this population despite enrichment efforts. We suggest there is an urgent need to understand how the chimpanzee mind copes with captivity, an issue with both scientific and welfare implications.

Yes, I know…. the parrots I’m talking about don’t live in zoos, and they’re not chimps; however, given all the similarities, and the data being presented from many different sources, shouldn’t we at least scientifically and meaningfully investigate this? If guardians really were the problem (which, really we humans are the problem as a whole in that we want to keep parrots as pets) wouldn’t we see the same behaviors across species? Why is self-mutilation so endemic and much more prevalent in Goffin’s cockatoo (Cacatua goffiniana) and in particular, Moluccan cockatoo (Cacatua moluccensis) than other parrot species? Does the cause only lie in the type of people who want these species of parrot, and not anything about the species themselves living in captivity?

Part of the problem with DVDs, seminars, books, Facebook groups and most of the advice given in whichever media form, is positive reinforcement utilizing applied behavior analysis (ABA). Specifically, it reduces each individual to a common blob, where you only identify the unwanted behavior, change it to the desired behavior and reinforce the new behavior, all utilizing a reward/motivator (i.e., treat). The reason for this reduction and rejection of labels is to avoid the need for interpretation.

heidenreich-its-not-your-fault-photo-2

This is a proven method for training animals. It helps curtail certain parrot behaviors, whether normal or abnormal, that can make living with them difficult for their human guardians, e.g., too much screaming, biting, and certain kinds of fear. It can also teach people to teach their parrots “tricks,” like riding a little bicycle or shooting baskets. This can be canned and individualized by the author-trainer to his/her methods of ABA, and sold to any consumer. But what about the large number of parrots who mutilate themselves to the point of gaping, muscle-deep wounds in their chests, under their wings, on thighs and abdomens? Or the ones who pull out their own feathers? Why is it so hard to “fix” these types of problems?

These problems are are difficult to treat because they are much more complex than just an unwanted behavior. These are the common symptoms of captive wild animals, whether in zoos, homes, parks, and the like, regardless of mammal or avian. Even if you could stop the behavior of self-harm (e.g., ABA, collaring), you still have an emotionally compromised parrot, and the underlying problems will manifest in some other way. Self-mutilation is also a symptom of very unhappy and deeply troubled humans. The reasons given for self-mutilation/self-injury in people are generally the same. This is from the nonprofit, Mental Health America:

People who self-injure commonly report they feel empty inside, over or under stimulated, unable to express their feelings, lonely, not understood by others…Self-injury is their way to cope with or relieve painful or hard-to-express feelings…Self-injury can also be a way to have control over your body when you can’t control anything else in your life.

This description certainly gave me pause. It describes perfectly the life in which wild animals in captivity find themselves. Captivity can never create the kinds of enrichment needed to fully stimulate parrots that would compete with how they would live in their native environments; they are unable to understand why they are unfulfilled; they have evolved to be around others most of their lives, rather than alone for hours at a time; we don’t understand their plucking, mutilating, screaming and biting as we continue to breed them and keep them as pets; parrots have evolved to make simple and complex decisions guiding their own lives moment by moment, and we take away just about every bit of their autonomy.

So, whether parrots are unsuited for life in captivity, or we are unsuited for providing them with what they need to live a happy and healthy life, the evidence is overwhelming.  If so many parrots have some sort of behavior issue (and how many is too many), and people need to rely on DVDs, books, seminars and ongoing education in order to help their parrots fit into our lives, I think it’s too much to ask for our selfish pleasures and needs. We need to focus on helping the parrots who are already here with us. Let’s adopt the ones who need homes, educate the public on the detriments for parrots when used as pets, and put an end to this trade.

 

 

Advertisements

10 comments on “Parrot Feather Picking, Self-Mutilation, and Other OCD Behaviors: It’s Not Your Fault.

  1. BETSY CAMP
    October 24, 2016

    I see way to many parrots in cages way to small for them and some with no toys Just like these stupid round cages Never should a parrot be in one of these

  2. PenderRedHed
    November 2, 2016

    Parrots should be permitted to fly freely in the home for a good part of the day. It not only gives them the freedom out of the cage, but it also gives them the exercise they need. Cages should be full of toys and foraging items to keep the parrot entertained when it’s in the cage. Even a huge telephone book on the bottom of the cage can provide the bird with hours of fun tearing it apart. The cage itself should be as large as possible.

    • Shari Mirojnick
      November 3, 2016

      It would be ideal if we could do this, but it’s not practical. Even if flying around the house all day long could come close to mirroring the amount of activity parrots evolved to have, most people work for at least eight hours a day. Parrots should always be monitored when loose around the house because of all the many dangers, and even when monitored, accidents happen too often. A large cage is subjective, but again, parrots have evolved to fly miles a day. As Marc Johnson of Foster Parrots, Ltd. says, “When asked how large of a cage a macaw needs, I say ’20 square miles.'” Another problem is that the parents of our companion parrots don’t get any of what we give to our companions. They are stuck in the same small flight (if they’re lucky enough to have a flight) and are given little in the way of enrichment. Parent parrots don’t get the things breeders tell the rest of us to give to our companion parrots. How is this morally okay?

      • PenderRedHed
        November 3, 2016

        I’m retired, so I am at home 98 percent of the time; thus, my birds are out of their cage and able to fly through my home. I spend most of my day with my two parrots either on my shoulder or playing and talking to them. I have a Goffin’s Cockatoo and a Solomon Island Eclectus. My birds are well taken care of, and they receive a good, healthy diet. Both are rescues. I did not take them out of the wild, and they would never adjust to living in the wild. They are very tame. And so I feel that, in my case and others like mine, I am making the best life for them as I can. I have a large, 6-foot cage for each bird, and they are placed in their cages for the night and if I leave the house for any reason. I would never leave them loose and unmonitored. Have you ever had a parrot? Or do you know anyone who had or has a parrot? I’m just wondering how you came to the conclusion that keeping parrots is morally wrong. If the bird has been a companion bird for years and cannot be released in the wild, then it is up to us to do the best that we can to raise and love them.

      • Shari Mirojnick
        November 3, 2016

        I don’t think you have to have experience keeping parrots to know it’s wrong to breed wild animals in captivity for use as pets. Or to let anyone breed endangered species for the pet trade, at the whim of the free market and trends. If the market of supply and demand are the driving forces in breeding these protected species, then their genetics and populations are less important than the bottom line. You also don’t need to have any experience with parrots to know that you can’t release domestically-raised animals back into the wild who were bred to be pets.

        However, I’ve been working with parrots in a professional manner since 1995. I started out working in a boutique parrot store where I learned to handle, groom, clean, feed, and hand-raise baby parrots. I worked with breeders, toy, cage and food companies, and rehomed adult parrots. In the mid-to-late 1990s, I worked at one of the largest parrot rescues in the US. From there, I adopted my third grey, and second special-needs parrot. I started my own mobile grooming and consultation business, helping pet owners and breeders with grooming, diet, and behavior. In 2006, I started working as a vet tech for a rehab vet, and in 2008, I started working for a board-certified, avian-only vet. I only stopped working there a few months ago. I admin a parrot advocacy group on Facebook, where there are many other advocates, as well as conservationists, biologists, authors, and a variety of people from all around the world, from whom I am constantly learning. Over the past 20-plus years, I have continued reading, attending seminars, and listening to others with much more experience, in order to keep me on top of the information out there.

        My first parrot was a rescue, a wild-caught African grey. That was in 1994, and we are still together. Since then, I have rescued around 20 parrots (mostly greys) many special-needs. Some have stayed with me for life-long care, and others have been very successfully placed in new homes.

        Does that work for you?

      • PenderRedHed
        November 3, 2016

        Yes, it does. But with all that experience, and by owning rescue parrots yourself, why ask me how this is morally OK? You should know everything that I just explained to you in my last post.

      • Shari Mirojnick
        November 3, 2016

        We can’t turn our backs on the ones who are already here, and need our help. Doing anything but giving them the best life possible in captivity wouldn’t be advocating for them. The questions are, how is it morally okay to continue to breed parrots-wild and endangered species-for the pet trade? If you think parrots should have all that you give to your parrots, shouldn’t that also apply to your parrots’ parents? The point of this post was to point out that there are many people out there who have parrots who suffer with these self-destructive behaviors despite doing everything they’ve been told to do. The very point of this is exactly what you did. You said that all parrots should have certain things, and then they will be happy, just as yours are. That implies that those with parrots with problem behaviors somehow aren’t doing something right. That isn’t true. Yes, there are dogs and cats who suffer from neurotic behaviors (I also worked with a board-certified veterinary behaviorist for a short period) but the numbers and severity doesn’t even come close to those of parrots in captivity. Why? Why are these behaviors also seen in other captive wild animals at a high rate? Because so many suffer from emotional trauma, because we can’t give parent parrots what we give our companion parrots, because many people aren’t capable of caring for parrots as they sexually mature, when do we say, “Enough?” How many have to suffer for us?

  3. LizTrupin
    November 25, 2016

    Aw, that’s my buddy Bebe from FP! ❤

  4. Nat
    April 25, 2017

    Back in February, I surrendered my parrot of 8+ years to a rehabiliation home because I had reached my near breaking point as I realized his feather plucking, which has been going on even before I first got him years ago from another home, was never going to get better under my care and I didn’t have the knowledge or means to help him get 100% well. It was the hardest decision I ever had to make to surrender him but I did it for him knowing all his social, medical and everyday needs would be provided by a professional rehabilitator who specializes in helping and rehoming parrots with behavorial problems. I can’t even tell you how many sleepless nights over the years that I’ve had knowing deep down that I couldn’t provide him with the best life. Even now I still feel guilty and wonder a lot about how he is doing now.

    • Shari Mirojnick
      May 22, 2017

      I think if you’re not constantly worried about the care you give your parrots, or don’t have some sort of guilt, you’re not paying attention. You’re not alone. ❤

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on October 23, 2016 by and tagged , , , , , , , , .

Navigation